Winter Lodge Warmth

Oak Chalet

Dining on Long Island invariably takes on a beach bungalow vibe when the summer months roll in—but the true taste of comfort resides in the Island’s cozier, more wintry establishments. These restaurants, preferably with a fireplace, dark paneling and wooden beams, can be the perfect remedy for the dark doldrums of winter when eaters need starchy, meaty and rich grub for warmth from the inside out.

Here’s a list of the island’s best lodge-inspired restaurants.

Oak Chalet

1940 Bellmore Ave., Bellmore

In this German, European and American restaurant, homemade is the rule and comfort is key. With a façade that looks like a cozy country manor and an interior reminiscent of the coziest basement lounge, Oak Chalet is one of Long Island’s singularly unique dining experiences. Hearty German recipes abound on the menu, with wienerschnitzel, bratwurst and potato pancakes bringing a satisfying heft to dinner.

Mirabelle Tavern


150 Main St., Stony Brook

This folksy throwback of an establishment is big on family comfort, with shareable plates, hearty soups and deep-fried delicacies that exorcise the cold. The pumpkin soup screams late autumn-early winter, while the fish and chips offer a faint memory of summer amid the cold-hard reality of the holiday season. The cheese plates also glow with warmth, complete with fruit compote and raisin walnut toast. The dining room’s centerpiece, a stone fireplace, provides an extra nudge of snug intimacy.

Jimmy Hays

Jimmy Hays

4310 Austin Blvd., Island Park

The South Shore is rife with casual eateries, so stepping into Jimmy Hays Steak House in Island Park can be a shock to the sensibilities. That sense of dismay is quickly abated with the hushed tones of the restaurant’s elegant, upscale atmosphere and a seared steak aroma that permeates the senses. The meat menu is exhaustive with dry-aged New York strip, filet mignon, Chateaubriand, double-thick lamb chops and more, while seafood also has a chance to dance with lobster, Atlantic salmon and irrepressible cioppino bouillabasse stew.


Want It In Print?

We now offer matted and framed copies of articles upon request.

Steve Mosco
Steve Mosco, the former editor-in-chief at Anton Media Group, is a columnist for Long Island Weekly's food and sports sections. He fancies himself a tastemaker, food influencer and king of all eaters.

Leave a Reply




A New Fitness Club Geared For Hofstra Females

Are you a college-aged girl who struggles to find a group of girls you can work out with? Do you find it hard going...

How Colleges Are Handling Back-To-School

A look inside school reopening plans within higher education Colleges, just like younger grades, have started school once again. From the protocols to the new...

Long Island, Let’s Lead on Climate

BY Laura Curran, Nassau County Executive As I write this, the skies above Long Island are filled with smoke blown east from the wildfires raging...

Local School Adds Holocaust Memoir By Syosset Resident To Curriculum

Holocaust education is mandatory in New York State, but one local writer wants Nassau County schools to use his father’s incredible story from World...

Tyra Banks Talks New Hosting Gig With Dancing With The Stars

Fascinated by the entertainment business at such a young age, Tyra Banks has proven to everyone that she is a force to be reckoned...

Get Updates Via Email

Enter your email to be updated with all the latest news and special announcements.