Should College Athletes Be Paid?

California is known to be much different than all the other 49 states. It has so many laws that clash with the rest of the country that it is too hard to pick out any one, but there may be an exception. For some unexplained reason California legislators have decided that college athletes should be paid for their services, irrespective of the size of the school.

The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), an archaic group if there ever was one, has decided that there should be some type of compensation formula. A pair of state legislators have decided that they have a new way to pay college athletes by imposing a 15 percent tax on all college teams with half going to the athletes, and the balance going to an injury fund.

The idea of a general tax might be a good idea if all colleges were created equal. New York State has 131 private colleges and only 20 percent of them have sports at the highest level, which is known as Division I. Of the 500,000 student-athletes in the state, only 2 percent go on to become professional athletes. Paying everyone some compensation makes little sense for a lot of reasons.

Presently, NCAA rules prohibit compensation for athletes in college competition. So a New York law that the players must be compensated from a wage fund, would lead to the disqualification of all the teams. The next issue is that a wage fund would turn every athlete’s relationship into an employer-employee situation.

The next most logical step would be the formation of a college player union. How about a union strike on the opening day of the season?

Under the bill proposed by Senator Kevin Parker and Assemblywoman Solages, the other half of the athletic tax would go to an injury fund. That would make sense if the students didn’t have any insurance. Currently, the NCAA requires students to have health insurance that will cover the first $90,000 in medical costs where there is a sport-related injury. Any injury costing over $90,000 is covered by the NCAA catastrophic injury plan.

There is no doubt that any college athlete who is having a successful career should be compensated for the use of their image or even any endorsement that they make of some product or event. That would reward a small number of athletes, and if they truly excel on the field the rules should be changed. Having been a state legislator I introduced many bills for study and comment. For now, that is what this legislation needs and nothing more.

As best as I can remember, being a college athlete was a lot of fun. Somehow, getting paid for a sport that you enjoy sends the wrong message.

Former State Assemblyman Jerry Kremer is a columnist for Anton Media Group and partner at Ruskin Moscou Faltischek in Uniondale. The views expressed are not necessarily those of the publisher or Anton Media Group.

Want It In Print?

We now offer matted and framed copies of articles upon request.

Jerry Kremer
Former State Assemblyman Jerry Kremer is a columnist for Long Island Weekly and partner at Ruskin Moscou Faltischek in Uniondale. The views expressed are not necessarily those of the publisher or Anton Media Group.


  1. Jerry, what are your thoughts on ? It would seem to weave through all the landmines you describe above. Fans could decide how much they wanted to contribute to the teams/positions that they support. We would love your feedback.

Leave a Reply




An Extreme Makeover From The Inside Out

By exercising self-discipline and self-control, we can achieve a spiritual transformation—an inner makeover that reflects outward, through our skin and our entire being.

A Fresh Generation Ford Reveals All-New F-150

The new F-150 kicks off a new generation as Ford optimizes its technology and reveals a hybrid version of the pickup.

Woodbury Native Is One Of America’s Top Young Entrepreneurs

Rachel Feigelson was named as one of Yahoo! Finance’s “top entrepreneurs of 2020 who have disrupted the status quo.”

The Transformation Of College

College is a process of personal transformation requiring you to move beyond our transactional culture.

Get Updates Via Email

Enter your email to be updated with all the latest news and special announcements.