The Milk Santa Really Wants Tomorrow

In collaboration with My Cookie Dealer in Deer Park, the Oyster Bay Brewing Company has the milk that Santa is really looking for tomorrow night when he stops by your house to deliver peace, joy and Christmas blessings.

Oyster Bay Brewing Company’s Santa’s Milk & Cookies (milk stout with an OG Chocolale Chip cookie from My Cookie Dealer (Christy Hinko)

Made with 30 pounds of My Cookie Dealer’s signature “OG Chocolate Chip” cookie, the brewery’s Santa’s Milk & Cookies milk stout is a dark, creamy, top-fermented beer, pleasing to the palate and pairs exceptionally well with, what other than any cookie from The Cookie Dealer.

“We had the idea and partnered with My Cookie Dealer last year during the pandemic,” said Gabe Haim, co-owner of Oyster Bay Brewing Company. “It was simply just two businesses co-marketing, trying to work together to help each other’s businesses.”

This year the brewery made 15 barrels of Santa’s Milk, split between cans and kegs. It was so wildly popular last year that they expect to be sold out before the new year again this year.

Santa’s Milk is 6.7 percent alcohol by volume and comes in a four-pack of 16 ounce cans ($18).

Have a hankering for an amazing chocolate chip cookie? Visit to learn more about the bakery and its two locations on Long Island.

Oyster Bay Brewing Company is open daily and is located a t 36 Audrey Ave. in Oyster Bay. Call ahead to check availability or visit for more details.


Editor’s note: As of Jan. 6, 2022, Oyster Bay Brewing Company reported that a limited supply of the milk stout is still available for purchase at the brewery (36 Audrey Ave., Oyster Bay). 

Christy Hinko
Christy Hinko is a managing editor at Anton Media Group. She is a New York Press Association (NYPA) and Press Club of Long Island (PCLI) award-winning writer and photographer.

Leave a Reply




Retail Row: Express Checkout

As fall begins, time to update some of the bigger local retail stories from the summer. Sun-Vet Mall in Holbrook was recently acquired by Syosset-based...

Fundraiser Set For Connor’s Kloset

Get tickets by September 26 Connor’s Kloset is a newly formed nonprofit 501c-3 helping those in need find sports equipment and medical supplies. It was...

Anton Exclusive: An Interview With “An American In Paris” Lead Brandon Haagenson

Before the Argyle Theatre in Babylon opened its newest show, An American in Paris, we had a chance to chat exclusively with Brandon Haagenson,...

Argyle Delivers Gershwins’ Classic “An American In Paris” To Close Season

Nailed it. The cast and crew at Babylon’s Argyle Theatre has set the bar high with its stellar season closer, An American in Paris,...

Rocking The Road For A Cure 13th Annual Motorcycle Run For Breast Cancer

Rocking the Road for a Cure’s 13th Annual Motorcycle Run for Breast Cancer will take place on Sunday, Oct. 2, at 9 a.m. Motorcycle...

Get Updates Via Email

Enter your email to be updated with all the latest news and special announcements.